Frequently Asked Questions
Whether you're new to the hobby or a seasoned collector, our team and resources are here to help.
FAQ
Where is Bleecker Trading located?
We have two locations. Our flagship is at 96 Christopher Street in the West Village, and our second shop is at 185 W 80th Street on the Upper West Side.
What services does Bleecker Trading provide?
We offer item valuation, card grading, collection buyouts, and access to our content studio for promotional purposes. We also host indoor and outdoor events for collectors to connect and engage.
Buying / Selling Cards
What types of collectibles do you offer?
Primarily trading cards — sports, TCG products including Pokémon, and other sports-related collectibles. We occasionally feature limited-run products and memorabilia from various entertainment industries.
How can I sell my collectibles to Bleecker Trading?
We offer collection buyouts. Visit our Sell Your Items page to submit your items for review.
What kind of cards does Bleecker Trading buy?
We focus on buying high-end cards with a value of $30 or more. We do not buy entire collections.
Does Bleecker Trading buy sports memorabilia?
No, we do not buy sports memorabilia.
Does Bleecker Trading pay in cash?
No. We pay our customers via PayPal or Zelle.
Events
What kind of events does Bleecker Trading have?
We host a range of events — trade nights, product release parties, kids' trading days, and more. Check our Upcoming Events page for the current schedule.
Can I host a private party at Bleecker Trading?
Yes. We've hosted birthday parties, corporate events, happy hours, and more. Reach out via our Host Your Event page.
Card Grading
Can I get my cards graded by PSA through Bleecker Trading?
Yes. Our PSA specialist is at our West Village location every Wednesday from 3–6 PM. Submissions are accepted during those hours only.
How will I be notified when my card returns from PSA?
You will receive an email as soon as your card comes back. If you haven't received an email, your card has not yet returned.
Shipping
Does Bleecker Trading offer online shipping?
Currently we offer in-store pickup and local Manhattan delivery. For shipping requests, email team@bleeckertrading.com and we'll do our best to accommodate.
Is ID required when picking up an online order?
Yes — a state-issued ID is required to pick up an online order. There are no exceptions.
Additional Information
Does Bleecker Trading offer any promotions?
All new customers receive $10 in store credit after their first purchase, applied to your account within 12 hours. All customers also earn 1% of every purchase back as store credit, redeemable in-store or online.
Does Bleecker Trading have a refund policy?
Yes — see our Refund Policy page for full details.
How can I confirm an item is in stock?
Use the chat widget in the bottom-right of your screen, or email team@bleeckertrading.com.
How can I follow Bleecker Trading on social media?
Find us on Instagram, TikTok, Twitter/X, and Facebook — all @bleeckertrading.
I have a question that isn't answered here — who can I contact?
Email team@bleeckertrading.com. We typically respond within 24 business hours.
Have a different question?
If you didn't find the answer you were looking for, contact us — we're here to help.
Get In Touch